Fans chose Sandra Diaz-Twine and CT Tamburello as the next Traitors because they are seen as strong strategic players who would make good Traitors on the show. However, Phaedra's decision to recruit Kate Chastain as a Traitor may backfire, as Kate's unpredictable nature could lead to betrayal in the end.
Fans believe that The Traitors US' last remaining Traitor, Phaedra Parks, should've given someone else the ultimatum of being recruited or murdered.
Many of Sandra's followers chose her, including The Traitors season 1 contestant Michael Davidson. Instagram user @fre_heaven wrote, "Sandra! Always recruit Sandra!!!" Instagram user @applesnider said, "[Sandra] for sure you wouldn’t get cold feet at the bonfire to take out someone at 3." Instagram user @debating_bravo stated, "I'd recruit Sandra, if you watch Survivor you would too lol."
Several Traitors US fans also thought that CT would've been a good choice for Phaedra to choose as her next fellow Traitor.
Hopefully, Phaedra made the wise decision to recruit Kate, but it is also true that Kate's unpredictable nature could ultimately lead her to betray Phaedra in the game. Kate has consistently demonstrated that she values personal gain over loyalty, and it is possible that she would make the same decision in The Traitors, potentially securing the entire prize pot for herself. While the game's objective is to win money, it is understandable for Phaedra to question the decision to risk their friendship for the potential reward.
Sandra and CT have both been suspected of being Traitors on The Traitors US, but their strategic abilities have shone through, allowing them to compete at a high level. Despite not being banished, their resilience and experience have made them formidable contenders.